Urgent Bid To Save Death Row Woman Set To Be First Executed By US State In 200 Years

Credit: Amnesty International & Tennessee Department Of Corrections
Anna Phillips
11 Min Read

An urgent bid has been made to save Christa Pike, the death row woman set to be the first executed by a US state in 200 years.

A death row woman facing execution later this month has become the focus of a fresh international campaign after new details about her childhood, mental health and decades behind bars emerged.

The 50-year-old has spent almost three decades awaiting execution after being convicted of a murder committed when she was just 18.

Her case has already attracted renewed attention because of the circumstances surrounding her childhood and the fact that Tennessee has not executed a woman for more than 200 years.

Now, with her execution date rapidly approaching, pressure is mounting on Tennessee Governor Bill Lee to intervene.

Her life took a devastating turn at a young age

Christa Gail Pike was sentenced to death in 1996, when she was only 20 years old.

The crime itself took place in January 1995, when she was 18.

She and her then-boyfriend were convicted over the killing of 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer, who had been an acquaintance from a Job Corps programme.

The circumstances of the murder were extremely serious, and the woman has never disputed that she played a role in what happened.

However, her lawyers have spent recent years asking whether the full story of her life was ever properly considered before she was condemned to death.

That question has become particularly significant because of what investigators and psychologists have since documented about her childhood.

She was just 18 when the crime happened

At the time of the murder, she was barely into adulthood.

Her lawyers have argued that her age should be considered alongside the trauma she had experienced throughout her childhood and her emerging mental health difficulties.

Her accomplice was only 17 at the time. That distinction proved crucial.

Under Tennessee law, he could not receive a death sentence because of his age, and he ultimately received a life sentence.

The woman, however, was 18, placing her on the other side of the legal boundary.

The Guardian has reported that Tennessee has never executed someone who was 18 when they committed their offence in the modern era of the death penalty. Seven people who were 18 at the time of murders were previously sentenced to death in the state, but their death sentences were ultimately vacated.

Her childhood contained years of trauma

Perhaps the most significant part of the current case concerns events that happened long before the murder.

According to a forensic evaluation cited in the clemency campaign, she experienced severe abuse and neglect as a child.

She was sexually abused at a very young age and later suffered further assaults during her childhood and teenage years.

The Guardian reported that several of these incidents were known to people in authority, yet the protection and support she needed did not follow.

A psychologist who interviewed her extensively later described a childhood in which she was effectively left without adequate protection, treatment or emotional support.

Those details were not fully presented to the jury that decided whether she should live or die.

That omission has become one of the central arguments in the latest effort to save her life.

The jury did not hear the full picture

After she was convicted of first-degree murder, the jury was left to decide whether she should receive life imprisonment or the death penalty.

Her current legal team says important mitigating evidence was not properly presented.

According to the Guardian’s reporting, the lawyer representing her during the sentencing stage was only four months out of law school and had never tried a murder case.

Her youth was not highlighted as a mitigating factor, and the jury was not given the full extent of the abuse she had suffered.

The jury also did not hear about her childhood suicide attempts or the mental health problems that were later diagnosed.

She was eventually diagnosed with bipolar disorder, something her lawyers say was not adequately recognised or treated when she was growing up.

The argument now being made is not that the murder should be ignored.

Instead, her lawyers say the circumstances surrounding her development, trauma and mental health should have been considered when deciding whether death was an appropriate punishment.

She has spent almost 30 years on death row

Since receiving her death sentence, she has spent decades in prison.

For much of that time, she was held in extremely restrictive conditions, spending years largely isolated from other prisoners.

A video recorded when she was sentenced in March 1996 has recently drawn particular attention.

In the footage, the young woman can be seen crying as the judge formally imposes the death sentence.

She then turns towards her mother and desperately asks whether she can hug her before being taken away.

She then turns towards her mother and desperately asks whether she can hug her before being taken away.

The clemency petition acknowledges her responsibility for the death of Colleen Slemmer and argues that she should remain imprisoned for the rest of her life.

The petition therefore centres on whether the ultimate punishment is appropriate, rather than whether she should escape punishment altogether.

Her lawyers have described her as deeply remorseful and say her behaviour and mental health have changed considerably during her decades in prison.

They also say she has become a source of guidance for other women arriving at the facility.

An urgent bid has been made to save the death row woman set to be the first executed by a US state in 200 years. Credit: Tennessee Department Of Corrections

Tennessee has not executed a woman for more than 200 years

The case has another extraordinary element.

Only three women have been executed by Tennessee since the state was founded in 1796.

The most recent execution of a woman took place in 1819 — more than two centuries ago.

That means the scheduled execution would represent a historic moment for the state.

The Tennessee Department of Correction currently has the execution scheduled for September 30, 2026, at Riverbend Maximum Security Institution.

The state has already begun making preparations, including arranging media access and selecting official witnesses.

On September 14, Tennessee issued media guidelines for the scheduled execution, confirming that preparations remain underway.

She has already faced years of legal battles

The death sentence has been challenged repeatedly over the years.

More recently, lawyers have raised concerns about the execution process itself, as well as her medical and psychological circumstances.

Her defence team has also continued to argue that the original sentencing process failed to properly account for the trauma and mental health difficulties documented in later assessments.

But with the execution date now approaching, attention has increasingly shifted towards whether Tennessee’s governor will use his power to commute the sentence.

Governor Bill Lee has the authority to commute a death sentence to life imprisonment.

According to her clemency lawyers, he has never granted clemency in a death penalty case.

That means the decision now facing the governor could determine whether the woman becomes the first female prisoner Tennessee has executed since the early 19th century.

An international campaign has now been launched

And this is where a fresh development has emerged.

On September 15, Amnesty International announced that its members around the world are urging Governor Bill Lee to stop the scheduled execution.

The organisation has issued an urgent action calling for clemency and asking the governor to commute the death sentence.

Amnesty International USA’s deputy director of research, Justin Mazzola, said the case reflected broader concerns surrounding the death penalty and the treatment of people who have experienced severe childhood trauma.

The organisation highlighted the woman’s age at the time of the crime, her history of abuse and the mental health problems that were not adequately addressed.

Amnesty also argued that scientific research has increasingly shown that brain development and psychological maturation continue into a person’s 20s — something that has become relevant to arguments about how young offenders should be treated.

People around the world are being urged to speak out

The Amnesty campaign means the effort to stop the execution is no longer confined to the woman’s legal team.

Members of the organisation worldwide are being encouraged to contact Governor Lee and call for clemency.

Amnesty International said it opposes the death penalty in every case and described capital punishment as a human rights issue.

The organisation also pointed to the continued use of executions in the United States despite the abolition of the death penalty in much of the world.

Its latest intervention comes just 15 days before the scheduled execution.

She is scheduled to be executed by lethal injection in Tennessee on September 30, 2026, unless her sentence is changed or the execution is otherwise halted.

Share This Article