Johnny Depp’s latest movie has sparked a heated debate among audiences, with some viewers calling for a boycott after discovering a controversial change to one of literature’s most beloved Christmas stories.
The actor takes on the iconic role of Ebenezer Scrooge in Ebenezer, a new adaptation of Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol.
However, while the film promises a darker interpretation of the festive classic, certain creative decisions have left viewers questioning whether the filmmakers have misunderstood the original story.
The controversy centres on the film’s portrayal of poverty, charity and the people Scrooge encounters throughout his journey.
Some viewers believe the changes undermine the important message at the heart of Dickens’ original novella.
Meanwhile, Depp’s casting has also proved divisive, with the actor’s highly publicized personal and legal controversies bringing another layer of debate to the movie’s release.
And one particular storyline has attracted especially fierce criticism, with viewers arguing that it gives Scrooge a reason to distrust the very people he is supposed to learn to help.
Fans react to Johnny Depp’s new Ebenezer movie
Johnny Depp’s upcoming Ebenezer movie has sparked angry reactions online, with some commenters calling for a boycott.
“This is disgusting. This movie should never have been made,” one wrote.
Another agreed: “I never planned on watching and now I feel even more justified in that decision.”
A third added: “Boycott this movie. This is appalling.”
Others questioned the filmmakers’ approach to the beloved Charles Dickens story.
“Wow. The filmmakers really misunderstood the assignment,” one commented, while another added: “Charles Dickens is turning in his grave.”
What is Johnny Depp’s new movie Ebenezer about?
Ebenezer is a new adaptation of Charles Dickens’ famous 1843 novella A Christmas Carol.
The film stars Johnny Depp as Ebenezer Scrooge, the miserly businessman whose obsession with money has left him bitter, selfish and unwilling to show compassion towards others.
However, his outlook on life is challenged when he receives a visit from the ghost of his former business partner, Jacob Marley, played by Ian McKellen.
Marley warns Scrooge that his selfish ways will have serious consequences and that he must change before it is too late.
Scrooge subsequently encounters three supernatural visitors: the Ghosts of Christmas Past, Present and Future.
Each takes him on a journey through different stages of his life, forcing him to confront his decisions and consider the consequences of his actions.
The original story explores themes of redemption, generosity, compassion and the treatment of disadvantaged people.
It also delivers an important message about wealth inequality and the responsibility of those with money to help people struggling to survive.
However, the new adaptation takes a considerably darker approach.
Directed by Ti West, who is known for horror movies including Pearl and MaXXXine, the production incorporates frightening supernatural imagery and violent sequences.
The film also features Rupert Grint as Bob Cratchit, Sam Claflin as Scrooge’s nephew Fred, Andrea Riseborough as the Ghost of Christmas Past and Tramell Tillman as the Ghost of Christmas Present.
The production runs for 116 minutes and carries a PG-13 rating in the United States.
Released in cinemas on November 13, 2026, Ebenezer promised audiences a fresh interpretation of a story that has been adapted countless times.
However, its decision to introduce additional horror elements and alter certain characters’ backstories has divided viewers.
Some critics have praised West’s gothic approach, while others believe the film’s changes do little to improve upon Dickens’ original.

Controversies surrounding Johnny Depp’s role in the film
Depp’s casting as Scrooge has attracted considerable attention, particularly because the actor remains a divisive figure following his highly publicized legal battles with his former wife, Amber Heard.
The pair’s relationship became the subject of two major defamation cases, which attracted worldwide attention and generated significant discussion about domestic abuse allegations.
In 2020, Depp lost a libel case against News Group Newspapers, the publisher of The Sun, after the newspaper described him as a wife beater.
Mr Justice Andrew Nicol concluded that the newspaper had established that its description was substantially true in relation to 12 of 14 alleged incidents.
Depp denied abusing Heard and subsequently pursued a separate defamation case against her in Virginia.
In June 2022, a jury found in Depp’s favor on three statements from Heard’s 2018 Washington Post opinion piece, awarding him $10 million in compensatory damages and $5 million in punitive damages, with the latter subsequently reduced to the state’s statutory limit.
Heard also won one claim on her counterclaim and received $2 million in compensatory damages.
The legal battles have continued to shape public discussion surrounding the actor’s career, with some fans remaining firmly supportive while others have criticized Hollywood for continuing to cast him in major productions.
His appearance in Ebenezer has therefore prompted renewed debate about whether audiences should separate an actor’s personal controversies from their work.
The movie marks Depp’s first major Hollywood studio project since the fallout from his legal disputes, making it an important moment in his return to mainstream American filmmaking.
He has continued working on other projects during that period, including the 2023 historical drama Jeanne du Barry, and directed Modì, Three Days on the Wing of Madness, released in 2024.
However, Ebenezer represents a particularly high-profile opportunity to reconnect with audiences.
The actor’s involvement has also made the movie a talking point beyond its actual storyline, with critics questioning whether the film’s redemption narrative invites comparisons with Depp’s own public image.
Some reviewers have explicitly raised this issue, arguing that watching the actor portray a character seeking forgiveness inevitably brings his personal controversies into the conversation.
Nevertheless, Depp has also received support from fans who have defended his casting and expressed excitement about seeing him return to a major studio production.
The debate surrounding the actor has therefore added another layer of interest to a movie that was already attracting attention because of its unusual interpretation of Dickens’ work.
The ‘deeply offensive’ scene that has left fans furious
The biggest controversy surrounding Ebenezer centres on its portrayal of poor people and charitable organizations.
In Dickens’ original novella, Scrooge’s refusal to help disadvantaged people is one of the clearest examples of his cruel and selfish nature.
His famous response to people asking him to donate to charity demonstrates just how little he cares about those struggling to survive.
The story ultimately challenges that attitude, showing how important generosity and compassion are.
However, Ti West’s adaptation introduces several changes that viewers believe significantly alter the message.
One of the biggest additions comes during the film’s opening sequence, which takes place before Jacob Marley’s death.
Scrooge witnesses a beggar outside his window who appears to be seeking donations from passers-by.
However, the man is eventually exposed as a fraud who has been pretending to be disadvantaged to trick people into giving him money.
The incident appears to reinforce Scrooge’s existing belief that people asking for financial assistance cannot necessarily be trusted.
The movie then introduces another significant change involving Scrooge’s former employer, Fezziwig.
In Dickens’ original story, Fezziwig is a generous and cheerful businessman who provides a sharp contrast to Scrooge’s miserable personality.
However, the new adaptation gives the character a much darker fate.
Fezziwig is murdered by a street beggar, providing Scrooge with another apparent reason to distrust the poor.
The film also introduces a storyline involving two charity workers who approach Scrooge for donations.
Rather than portraying them as well-meaning individuals trying to help disadvantaged people, the movie suggests that they are dishonest and are pocketing the money intended for those in need.
Their behaviour is later exposed further when the Ghost of Christmas Future reveals that they are involved in a scheme to steal Fred’s inheritance using a forged will.
These changes have prompted criticism from viewers who believe the filmmakers have effectively given Scrooge justification for his behaviour.
One viewer wrote: “The whole bit with the Charity collectors being con men is just a really, really gross change.
“Especially given the whole reason Dickens wrote the book was as an alternative to a boring political paper. He wanted to reach a larger audience with his message about the treatment of the poor.”
Another added: “What do you *mean* they made the charity workers grifters in this version.”
One of the central complaints was that almost every impoverished character in the film is presented negatively, including bullies, criminals, fraudsters and even a murderer.
The portrayal of charity workers also attracted criticism, with viewers arguing that depicting them as dishonest reinforces harmful stereotypes about people working to support disadvantaged communities.
Critics of the new movie believe that portraying several disadvantaged characters as criminals risks shifting the focus away from that message.
The Los Angeles Times also highlighted the film’s changes, particularly the decision to have Fezziwig stabbed to death by a street child and to portray the charity workers as dishonest.
However, not everyone has interpreted the changes in the same way.
The Guardian described the production as an unexpectedly watchable new version of the Dickens classic, acknowledging its darker creative decisions without dismissing the entire adaptation.
Ultimately, the disagreement highlights how strongly audiences feel about A Christmas Carol and the themes that have made it a Christmas favourite for generations.
For some viewers, the darker approach is an interesting way to revisit a familiar tale.
For others, changing the portrayal of poverty and charity goes too far, leaving them questioning whether the filmmakers have understood what Dickens was trying to say.
And with the film attracting criticism over these decisions, Depp’s latest movie has certainly given audiences plenty to argue about.

